The exact motion or nomination the chamber put to a vote.
Recorded vote
TO RECOMMIT H. J. RES. 59, TO COMMITTEE ON WAYS AND MEANS WITH AMENDMENT WHICH ELIMINATES "DEC. 31, 1916" -INSERTS IN LIEU THEREOF "APRIL 30, 1916"; THAT IS, THAT THE PROVISIONS OF INTERNAL REVENUE ACT BE EXTE…
The official yea, nay, present, and not-voting totals.
Every member's recorded position linked directly to their file.
- This vote predates the chambers' digital roll-call records (Senate begins 1989, House 1990). It is reproduced from the official Journals of Congress as compiled by Voteview (UCLA).
How the vote fell · we worked out this outcome from the vote counts (see sources)
What was on the floor
No separate text document applies to this vote.
Every roll call on HJR59
How each state's members voted
In 10 states every member on the roll voted yes; in 7 every one voted no; 31 were split. Each square is a state, placed roughly where it sits on the map. Select a state to see how each of its members voted.
- All yes
- All no
- Split
- No yes or no vote
- Alaska: no member on this roll call
- Maine: 3 yes, 1 no
- Vermont: 2 yes, 0 no
- New Hampshire: 2 yes, 0 no
- Washington: 4 yes, 1 no
- Idaho: 2 yes, 0 no
- Montana: 0 yes, 2 no
- North Dakota: 3 yes, 0 no
- Minnesota: 9 yes, 1 no
- Illinois: 18 yes, 8 no, 1 did not vote yes or no
- Wisconsin: 8 yes, 3 no
- Michigan: 11 yes, 2 no
- New York: 20 yes, 17 no, 5 did not vote yes or no
- Rhode Island: 2 yes, 1 no
- Massachusetts: 10 yes, 2 no, 4 did not vote yes or no
- Oregon: 3 yes, 0 no
- Nevada: 1 yes, 0 no
- Wyoming: 1 yes, 0 no
- South Dakota: 2 yes, 1 no
- Iowa: 10 yes, 1 no
- Indiana: 2 yes, 9 no, 2 did not vote yes or no
- Ohio: 11 yes, 9 no, 2 did not vote yes or no
- Pennsylvania: 29 yes, 6 no, 1 did not vote yes or no
- New Jersey: 8 yes, 3 no, 1 did not vote yes or no
- Connecticut: 5 yes, 0 no
- California: 6 yes, 4 no
- Utah: 1 yes, 1 no
- Colorado: 3 yes, 1 no
- Nebraska: 3 yes, 3 no
- Missouri: 2 yes, 12 no, 1 did not vote yes or no
- Kentucky: 1 yes, 8 no, 2 did not vote yes or no
- West Virginia: 3 yes, 3 no
- Virginia: 1 yes, 9 no
- Maryland: 1 yes, 5 no
- Delaware: 1 yes, 0 no
- Arizona: 0 yes, 1 no
- New Mexico: 1 yes, 0 no
- Kansas: 2 yes, 6 no
- Arkansas: 1 yes, 6 no
- Tennessee: 1 yes, 6 no, 3 did not vote yes or no
- North Carolina: 1 yes, 9 no
- South Carolina: 0 yes, 7 no
- District of Columbia: no member on this roll call
- Oklahoma: 1 yes, 7 no
- Louisiana: 1 yes, 7 no
- Mississippi: 0 yes, 7 no
- Alabama: 0 yes, 9 no
- Georgia: 0 yes, 12 no
- Hawaii: no member on this roll call
- Texas: 1 yes, 16 no, 1 did not vote yes or no
- Florida: 0 yes, 4 no
Numbers are yes–no. Members who did not vote, voted present, or were paired are counted in each state's list below.
Alabama 0 yes, 9 no
- Edward Berton Almon (Democrat) — NAY
- Fred Leonard Blackmon (Democrat) — NAY
- George Huddleston (Democrat) — NAY
- Henry Bascom Steagall (Democrat) — NAY
- James Thomas Heflin (Democrat) — NAY
- John Lawson Burnett (Democrat) — NAY
- John William Abercrombie (Democrat) — NAY
- Stanley Hubert Dent Jr. (Democrat) — NAY
- William Bacon Oliver (Democrat) — NAY
Arkansas 1 yes, 6 no
Arizona 0 yes, 1 no
California 6 yes, 4 no
- Charles Forrest Curry (Republican) — YEA
- Charles Hiram Randall (Prohibitionist) — NAY
- Denver Samuel Church (Democrat) — NAY
- Everis Anson Hayes (Republican) — YEA
- John Arthur Elston (Progressive) — YEA
- John Edward Raker (Democrat) — NAY
- John Ignatius Nolan (Republican) — YEA
- Julius Kahn (Republican) — YEA
- William Dennison Stephens (Progressive) — YEA
- William Kettner (Democrat) — NAY
Colorado 3 yes, 1 no
Connecticut 5 yes, 0 no
Delaware 1 yes, 0 no
Florida 0 yes, 4 no
Georgia 0 yes, 12 no
- Carl Vinson (Democrat) — NAY
- Charles Gordon Edwards (Democrat) — NAY
- Charles Robert Crisp (Democrat) — NAY
- Dudley Mays Hughes (Democrat) — NAY
- Frank Park (Democrat) — NAY
- Gordon Lee (Democrat) — NAY
- James Walter Wise (Democrat) — NAY
- John Randall Walker (Democrat) — NAY
- Samuel Joelah Tribble (Democrat) — NAY
- Thomas Montgomery Bell (Democrat) — NAY
- William Charles Adamson (Democrat) — NAY
- William Schley Howard (Democrat) — NAY
Iowa 10 yes, 1 no
- Burton Erwin Sweet (Republican) — YEA
- Cassius Clay Dowell (Republican) — YEA
- Charles Augustus Kennedy (Republican) — YEA
- Christian William Ramseyer (Republican) — YEA
- Frank Plowman Woods (Republican) — YEA
- Gilbert Nelson Haugen (Republican) — YEA
- Harry Edward Hull (Republican) — YEA
- Horace Mann Towner (Republican) — YEA
- James William Good (Republican) — YEA
- Thomas Jefferson Steele (Democrat) — NAY
- William Raymond Green (Republican) — YEA
Idaho 2 yes, 0 no
Illinois 18 yes, 8 no, 1 did not vote yes or no
- Adolph Joachim Sabath (Democrat) — NAY
- Burnett Mitchell Chiperfield (Republican) — YEA
- Charles Eugene Fuller (Republican) — YEA
- Claudius Ulysses Stone (Democrat) — NAY
- Clyde Howard Tavenner (Democrat) — NAY
- Edward Everett Denison (Republican) — YEA
- Edward John King (Republican) — YEA
- Frank Buchanan (Democrat) — YEA
- Frederick Albert Britten (Republican) — YEA
- George Edmund Foss (Republican) — YEA
- Henry Thomas Rainey (Democrat) — NAY
- Ira Clifton Copley (Progressive) — YEA
- James McAndrews (Democrat) — NAY
- James Robert Mann (Republican) — YEA
- James Thomas McDermott (Democrat) — NAY
- John Allen Sterling (Republican) — YEA
- John Charles McKenzie (Republican) — YEA
- Joseph Gurney Cannon (Republican) — YEA
- Loren Edgar Wheeler (Republican) — YEA
- Martin Barnaby Madden (Republican) — YEA
- Martin David Foster (Democrat) — NAY
- Thomas Gallagher (Democrat) — NOT VOTING
- Thomas Sutler Williams (Republican) — YEA
- William August Rodenberg (Republican) — YEA
- William Brown McKinley (Republican) — YEA
- William Elza Williams (Democrat) — NAY
- William Warfield Wilson (Republican) — YEA
Indiana 2 yes, 9 no, 2 did not vote yes or no
- Charles Lieb (Democrat) — NOT VOTING
- Cyrus Cline (Democrat) — NAY
- Finly Hutchinson Gray (Democrat) — NAY
- George Washington Rauch (Democrat) — NAY
- Henry A. Barnhart (Democrat) — NAY
- John Alfred Adair (Democrat) — NOT VOTING
- Lincoln Dixon (Democrat) — NAY
- Martin Andrew Morrison (Democrat) — NAY
- Merrill Moores (Republican) — YEA
- Ralph Wilbur Moss (Democrat) — NAY
- William Allen Cullop (Democrat) — NAY
- William Elijah Cox (Democrat) — NAY
- William Robert Wood (Republican) — YEA
Kansas 2 yes, 6 no
Kentucky 1 yes, 8 no, 2 did not vote yes or no
- Alben William Barkley (Democrat) — NAY
- Arthur Blythe Rouse (Democrat) — NAY
- Ben Johnson (Democrat) — NAY
- Caleb Powers (Republican) — YEA
- David Hayes Kincheloe (Democrat) — NAY
- Harvey Helm (Democrat) — NAY
- James Campbell Cantrill (Democrat) — NAY
- John Wesley Langley (Republican) — NOT VOTING
- Joseph Swagar Sherley (Democrat) — NAY
- Robert Young Thomas Jr. (Democrat) — NAY
- William Jason Fields (Democrat) — NOT VOTING
Louisiana 1 yes, 7 no
Massachusetts 10 yes, 2 no, 4 did not vote yes or no
- Allen Towner Treadway (Republican) — YEA
- Augustus Peabody Gardner (Republican) — YEA
- Calvin DeWitt Paige (Republican) — YEA
- Ernest William Roberts (Republican) — PRESENT
- Frederick Huntington Gillett (Republican) — YEA
- Frederick William Dallinger (Republican) — YEA
- George Holden Tinkham (Republican) — YEA
- James Ambrose Gallivan (Democrat) — NOT VOTING
- John Jacob Rogers (Republican) — YEA
- Joseph Walsh (Republican) — YEA
- Michael Francis Phelan (Democrat) — NOT VOTING
- Peter Francis Tague (Democrat) — NAY
- Richard Olney (Democrat) — NAY
- Samuel Ellsworth Winslow (Republican) — NOT VOTING
- William Henry Carter (Republican) — YEA
- William Stedman Greene (Republican) — YEA
Maryland 1 yes, 5 no
Maine 3 yes, 1 no
Michigan 11 yes, 2 no
- Carl Edgar Mapes (Republican) — YEA
- Charles Archibald Nichols (Republican) — YEA
- Edward La Rue Hamilton (Republican) — YEA
- Frank Douglas Scott (Republican) — YEA
- Frank Ellsworth Doremus (Democrat) — NAY
- George Alvin Loud (Republican) — YEA
- James Campbell McLaughlin (Republican) — YEA
- John M. C. Smith (Republican) — YEA
- Joseph Warren Fordney (Republican) — YEA
- Louis Convers Cramton (Republican) — YEA
- Patrick Henry Kelley (Republican) — YEA
- Samuel Willard Beakes (Democrat) — NAY
- William Francis James (Republican) — YEA
Minnesota 9 yes, 1 no
- Andrew John Volstead (Republican) — YEA
- Carl Chester van Dyke (Democrat) — NAY
- Charles August Lindbergh (Republican) — YEA
- Charles Russell Davis (Republican) — YEA
- Clarence Benjamin Miller (Republican) — YEA
- Franklin Fowler Ellsworth (Republican) — YEA
- George Ross Smith (Republican) — YEA
- Halvor Steenerson (Republican) — YEA
- Sydney Anderson (Republican) — YEA
- Thomas David Schall (Progressive) — YEA
Missouri 2 yes, 12 no, 1 did not vote yes or no
- Charles Ferris Booher (Democrat) — NAY
- Clement Cabell Dickinson (Democrat) — NAY
- Courtney Walker Hamlin (Democrat) — NOT VOTING
- Dorsey William Shackleford (Democrat) — NAY
- Jacob Edwin Meeker (Republican) — YEA
- James Tilghman Lloyd (Democrat) — NAY
- Joseph James Russell (Democrat) — NAY
- Joshua Willis Alexander (Democrat) — NAY
- Leonidas Carstarphen Dyer (Republican) — YEA
- Perl D. Decker (Democrat) — NAY
- Thomas Lewis Rubey (Democrat) — NAY
- Walter Lewis Hensley (Democrat) — NAY
- William Leo Igoe (Democrat) — NAY
- William Patterson Borland (Democrat) — NAY
- William Waller Rucker (Democrat) — NAY
Mississippi 0 yes, 7 no
Montana 0 yes, 2 no
- John Morgan Evans (Democrat) — NAY
- Tom Stout (Democrat) — NAY
North Carolina 1 yes, 9 no
- Charles Manly Stedman (Democrat) — NAY
- Claude Kitchin (Democrat) — NAY
- Edward William Pou (Democrat) — NAY
- Edwin Yates Webb (Democrat) — NAY
- George Ezekial Hood (Democrat) — NAY
- Hannibal Lafayette Godwin (Democrat) — NAY
- James Jefferson Britt (Republican) — YEA
- John Humphrey Small (Democrat) — NAY
- Robert Lee Doughton (Democrat) — NAY
- Robert Newton Page (Democrat) — NAY
North Dakota 3 yes, 0 no
Nebraska 3 yes, 3 no
New Hampshire 2 yes, 0 no
New Jersey 8 yes, 3 no, 1 did not vote yes or no
- Archibald Chapman Hart (Democrat) — NAY
- Dow Henry Drukker (Republican) — YEA
- Edward Winthrop Gray (Republican) — YEA
- Elijah Cubberley Hutchinson (Republican) — YEA
- Frederick Reimold Lehlbach (Republican) — YEA
- Isaac Bacharach (Republican) — YEA
- James Alphonsus Hamill (Democrat) — NAY
- John Henry Capstick (Republican) — YEA
- John Joseph Eagan (Democrat) — NAY
- Richard Wayne Parker (Republican) — YEA
- Thomas Joseph Scully (Democrat) — NOT VOTING
- William John Browning (Republican) — YEA
New Mexico 1 yes, 0 no
Nevada 1 yes, 0 no
New York 20 yes, 17 no, 5 did not vote yes or no
- Bertrand Hollis Snell (Republican) — YEA
- Charles Bennett Smith (Democrat) — NOT VOTING
- Charles Bonnell Ward (Republican) — YEA
- Charles Mann Hamilton (Republican) — NOT VOTING
- Charles Pope Caldwell (Democrat) — NAY
- Daniel Angelus Driscoll (Democrat) — NAY
- Daniel Joseph Griffin (Democrat) — NAY
- Daniel Joseph Riordan (Democrat) — NAY
- Edmund Platt (Republican) — YEA
- Frederick William Rowe (Republican) — YEA
- George Murray Hulbert (Democrat) — NAY
- George William Loft (Democrat) — NOT VOTING
- George Winthrop Fairchild (Republican) — YEA
- Harry Hayt Pratt (Republican) — YEA
- Harry Howard Dale (Democrat) — NAY
- Henry Bruckner (Democrat) — NAY
- Henry Gold Danforth (Republican) — YEA
- Homer Peter Snyder (Republican) — YEA
- Isaac Siegel (Republican) — YEA
- James Paul Maher (Democrat) — NAY
- James Southworth Parker (Republican) — YEA
- James William Husted (Republican) — YEA
- John Francis Carew (Democrat) — NAY
- John Joseph Fitzgerald (Democrat) — NAY
- Joseph Vincent Flynn (Democrat) — NAY
- Luther Wright Mott (Republican) — YEA
- Meyer London (Socialist) — NAY
- Michael Francis Conry (Democrat) — NAY
- Michael Francis Farley (Democrat) — NAY
- Norman Judd Gould (Republican) — YEA
- Oscar William Swift (Republican) — YEA
- Peter Joseph Dooling (Democrat) — NAY
- Reuben Locke Haskell (Republican) — YEA
- Rollin Brewster Sanford (Republican) — NOT VOTING
- Stephen Wallace Dempsey (Republican) — YEA
- Thomas Byrne Dunn (Republican) — YEA
- Thomas Gedney Patten (Democrat) — NAY
- Walter Marion Chandler (Progressive) — YEA
- Walter Warren Magee (Republican) — YEA
- William Barclay Charles (Republican) — YEA
- William Stiles Bennet (Republican) — NOT VOTING
- Woodson Ratcliffe Oglesby (Democrat) — NAY
Ohio 11 yes, 9 no, 2 did not vote yes or no
- Alfred Gaither Allen (Democrat) — NAY
- Arthur Warren Overmyer (Democrat) — NAY
- Charles Cyrus Kearns (Republican) — YEA
- Clement Laird Brumbaugh (Democrat) — NAY
- David Adams Hollingsworth (Republican) — YEA
- Edwin Darlington Ricketts (Republican) — YEA
- Henry Ivory Emerson (Republican) — YEA
- Isaac R. Sherwood (Democrat) — NAY
- John Alexander Key (Democrat) — NAY
- John Gordon Cooper (Republican) — YEA
- Joshua Edward Russell (Republican) — YEA
- Nelson Edwin Matthews (Republican) — YEA
- Nicholas Longworth (Republican) — YEA
- Robert Crosser (Democrat) — NAY
- Robert Mauck Switzer (Republican) — PRESENT
- Roscoe Conkling McCulloch (Republican) — YEA
- Seward Henry Williams (Republican) — YEA
- Simeon Davison Fess (Republican) — NOT VOTING
- Warren Gard (Democrat) — NAY
- William Albert Ashbrook (Democrat) — NAY
- William Crittenden Mooney (Republican) — YEA
- William Gordon (Democrat) — NAY
Oklahoma 1 yes, 7 no
- Charles David Carter (Democrat) — NAY
- Dick Thompson Morgan (Republican) — YEA
- James Sanford Davenport (Democrat) — NAY
- James Vernon McClintic (Democrat) — NAY
- Joseph Bryan Thompson (Democrat) — NAY
- Scott Ferris (Democrat) — NAY
- William Henry David Murray (Democrat) — NAY
- William Wirt Hastings (Democrat) — NAY
Oregon 3 yes, 0 no
Pennsylvania 29 yes, 6 no, 1 did not vote yes or no
- Aaron Shenk Kreider (Republican) — YEA
- Abraham Lincoln Keister (Republican) — YEA
- Andrew Jackson Barchfeld (Republican) — YEA
- Arthur Granville Dewalt (Democrat) — NAY
- Benjamin Kurtz Focht (Republican) — YEA
- Charles Hedding Rowland (Republican) — YEA
- Cyrus William Beales (Republican) — YEA
- Daniel Franklin Lafean (Republican) — YEA
- Edgar Raymond Kiess (Republican) — YEA
- George Potter Darrow (Republican) — YEA
- George Scott Graham (Republican) — YEA
- George Washington Edmonds (Republican) — YEA
- Henry Joseph Steele (Democrat) — NAY
- Henry Wilson Temple (Republican) — YEA
- Henry Winfield Watson (Republican) — YEA
- John Joseph Casey (Democrat) — NAY
- John Mary Morin (Republican) — YEA
- John Richard Farr (Republican) — YEA
- John Roger Kirkpatrick Scott (Republican) — NOT VOTING
- John Vandling Lesher (Democrat) — NAY
- Joseph Hampton Moore (Republican) — YEA
- Louis Thomas McFadden (Republican) — YEA
- Mahlon Morris Garland (Republican) — YEA
- Michael Liebel Jr. (Democrat) — NAY
- Peter Edward Costello (Republican) — YEA
- Robert Douglas Heaton (Republican) — YEA
- Robert Freeman Hopwood (Republican) — YEA
- Samuel Henry Miller (Republican) — YEA
- Solomon Taylor North (Republican) — YEA
- Stephen Geyer Porter (Republican) — YEA
- Thomas Spencer Crago (Republican) — YEA
- Thomas Stalker Butler (Republican) — YEA
- Warren Worth Bailey (Democrat) — NAY
- William Henry Coleman (Republican) — YEA
- William Scott Vare (Republican) — YEA
- William Walton Griest (Republican) — YEA
Rhode Island 2 yes, 1 no
South Carolina 0 yes, 7 no
South Dakota 2 yes, 1 no
Tennessee 1 yes, 6 no, 3 did not vote yes or no
- Cordell Hull (Democrat) — NAY
- Finis James Garrett (Democrat) — NAY
- John Austin Moon (Democrat) — NAY
- Joseph Wellington Byrns (Democrat) — NAY
- Kenneth Douglas McKellar (Democrat) — NOT VOTING
- Lemuel Phillips Padgett (Democrat) — NOT VOTING
- Richard Wilson Austin (Republican) — PRESENT
- Sam Riley Sells (Republican) — YEA
- Thetus Willrette Sims (Democrat) — NAY
- William Cannon Houston (Democrat) — NAY
Texas 1 yes, 16 no, 1 did not vote yes or no
- Alexander White Gregg (Democrat) — NAY
- Atkins Jefferson McLemore (Democrat) — NAY
- Eugene Black (Democrat) — NAY
- George Farmer Burgess (Democrat) — NAY
- Hatton William Sumners (Democrat) — NAY
- James Harvey Davis (Democrat) — NAY
- James Luther Slayden (Democrat) — NOT VOTING
- James Paul Buchanan (Democrat) — NAY
- James Young (Democrat) — NAY
- Joe Henry Eagle (Democrat) — NAY
- John Hall Stephens (Democrat) — NAY
- John Nance Garner (Democrat) — NAY
- Martin Dies (Democrat) — NAY
- Oscar Callaway (Democrat) — YEA
- Robert Lee Henry (Democrat) — NAY
- Rufus Hardy (Democrat) — NAY
- Samuel Taliaferro Rayburn (Democrat) — NAY
- William Robert Smith (Democrat) — NAY
Utah 1 yes, 1 no
Virginia 1 yes, 9 no
- Andrew Jackson Montague (Democrat) — NAY
- Campbell Bascom Slemp (Republican) — YEA
- Carter Glass (Democrat) — NAY
- Charles Creighton Carlin (Democrat) — NAY
- Edward Everett Holland (Democrat) — NAY
- Edward Watts Saunders (Democrat) — NAY
- Henry De La Warr Flood (Democrat) — NAY
- James Hay (Democrat) — NAY
- Walter Allen Watson (Democrat) — NAY
- William Atkinson Jones (Democrat) — NAY
Vermont 2 yes, 0 no
Washington 4 yes, 1 no
Wisconsin 8 yes, 3 no
- Edward Everts Browne (Republican) — YEA
- Henry Allen Cooper (Republican) — YEA
- Irvine Luther Lenroot (Republican) — YEA
- James Archibald Frear (Republican) — YEA
- John Jacob Esch (Republican) — YEA
- John Mandt Nelson (Republican) — YEA
- Michael Edmund Burke (Democrat) — NAY
- Michael Kieran Reilly (Democrat) — NAY
- Thomas Frank Konop (Democrat) — NAY
- William Henry Stafford (Republican) — YEA
- William Joseph Cary (Republican) — YEA
West Virginia 3 yes, 3 no
Wyoming 1 yes, 0 no
Every vote, by name — 431 members
Select any member to pull their file.
